The International Newsletter of PR Measurement from | Contents | Subscribe | MeasuresOfSuccess.com |
   

April 30th, 2003

Measurement Maven of the Month

Ward White,
Vice President,
Northwestern Mutual

Having just completed a Webinar with Ward, I can tell you that this man is the ultimate accountable PR pro. As head of communications for the nation’s largest provider of individual life insurance, he has a million better things to do than to help me spread the measurement gospel. But there he was, taking several hours out of his busy day to tell some 300 faceless attendees how and why Northwestern Mutual measures its reputation.

White's measurement excellence owes a lot to his CEO, who from day one outlined specific priorities for the organization. It was up to White to figure out how to translate those corporate goals into measurable communications objectives.

Northwestern Mutual has topped Fortune’s "America's Most Admired Companies" list in its category ever since the list was started in 1983. For some, that might be enough measurement. But White realized that was but a small piece of the measurement pie. Taking the perspective that PR is all about relationships and that you need to measure those relationships, White has set up relationship measurement programs with employees, agents, investors and the media. He conducts ongoing studies in every area. See our article on measuring relationships in this issue.

Okay, in the interest of full disclosure, let me confess up front that I sit on the Board of Directors of the IPR, of which Ward is the Co-Chair. Be that as it may, the fact that he hasn't just read the IPR’s paper on Guidelines for Measuring Relationships, but has actually implemented those guidelines and can talk comfortably about the Hon/Grunig model, is impressive and earns him the illustrious award of Measurement Maven of the Month.

Measurement Menace of the Month

Joseph Sun, CEO,
e21 Corporation

e21 is a Silicon Valley-based marketing communications company that has recently published an article on its Web site called “Measuring PR Effectiveness.” At best, it is typical agency blather about why they’re accountable for results and therefore readers should hire them. But at worst, the section under Advertising Value Equivalency is downright misleading and dangerous. It purports to provide “a very clean ROI number.” To whom? The accountants at Enron?

There is absolutely no link between return on investment and Advertising Value Equivalency. What Ad Value Equivalency tells you is how many inches of ink you placed in a month and what it might cost you to buy that ink. Period.

e21 includes no definition of return on investment—and apparently they are confused—so I will refresh their memory:

  • Investment is budget dollars.
  • Return is profit, revenue or something equivalent.
  • Return on investment is profit minus the budget (return minus investment).

There is not presently, nor has their ever been, a scientifically proven study that ties ad value to profit, or even sales. There are studies that show that the visibility in the media of your messages or your brand or good news about your company has a direct correlation to loyalty, preference and, in some cases, sales. But the idea that a given ad value leads to a quantifiable return of any sort has the credibility of the Iraqi Information Minister. —KDP

   

New articles
in this issue:

Articles with red arrows require a subscription:

How To Evaluate Public Relationships

Who Needs to Measure Reputation When You’ve Got Fortune? We Asked the Experts...

Sumo Wrestlers and Pivot Sales Prove PR Effectiveness

What Really Is Reputation?

Buyers’ Guide to
Reputation Indexes

Moves & Shakeouts

Articles with black arrows do not require a subscription:

The Paine of Measurement

Can Augusta National’s Reputation be Saved?

Ask Dr. Paine

The Miami Papers

Letters to the Editor

The Monthly Measurement Menace and Maven

The PR Weather Report

Measurement Events

Help Wanted

 

Sign up now for your free monthly One-Minute Benchmarking Bulletin and stay up to date on PR and marketing measurement around the world. Just type your email address below and click on the Sign Up button:

 

Three Reasons Why You Should Subscribe to The Measurement Standard:

1. You’ll learn how to use hard numbers to prove the results of your PR efforts.

2. You’ll learn which are the right vendors for your measurement projects.

3. You’ll learn how to design your program right from the start to be easily measureable.

Click here to
subscribe now!

(It’s 100%
money-back guaranteed!)

 

Struggling to set up your measurement system?
Katie Delahaye Paine can help you at measuresofsuccess.com

 

Stock your reference library at the Measurement Mall, where you'll find books, Buyer’s Guides, Complete Handbooks and a selection of white papers.
[let’s go shopping]
 
 

|Contents | To The Editor

Copyright 2003, all rights reserved.
Reprint information is here.

133 Islington Street, Portsmouth, NH 03801
603-431-6967 www.measuresofsuccess.com